Why Do People Plagiarize?

This will be my last post on plagiarism for a while (I haven't said this before, have I?) I know must seem obsessed at this point, but it's an important topic for writers. Besides, it's a hot topic with the media right now for obvious reasons. Anyway, Jack Shafer posted an article about plagiarists and some reasons they do what they do.

So for anyone who is interested, the article brings up some interesting points, and they make a lot of sense, especially the one comparing literary theft to shoplifting and the thrill the so called writer gets from it and the fact that it is habit forming. After all, if you plagiarize papers in high school and college and don't get caught, what's to stop you from doing it professionally.

What if the person was never a good writer to begin with? I'm sure that would be a difficult one to face, but it's definitely one to consider.

Keep in mind, Shafer is not defending or justifying plagiarism, and neither would I. Stealing someone else's work is just as much a crime as stealing his/her wallet. The best way to avoid getting caught is not doing it in the first place.

All right, last post on plagiarism. Really...

Posted in literary theft | plagiarism | plagiarist | plagiarize | steal Musings of a Wordsmith | delicious | digg | reddit | 1832 reads

Submitted by gom jabbar on April 29, 2006 - 1:11pm.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Radreview | April 29, 2006 - 1:28pm

... first, they honestly believe in that point, although they didn'actually write it, it resonated with them and they want to spread the word fast. Their passion and in-a-hurry attitude affected their judgment, an indictment on the too-busy nature of our ways.


gom jabbar | April 29, 2006 - 2:11pm

I'm not sure that I completely agree with it, but it's something to think about. One thing I should have added that I left out in my rush to post this is that people don't always realize that they are plagiarizing because they don't know what all it encompasses. This is one thing I've observed from people who have had posts deleted here for plagiarism. They didn't understand what they did wrong. Sure, we all agree that a direct copy of someone else's work with giving credit to the source is wrong, but if you paraphrase a few words and claim it as your own. That's still plagiarism.

Anyway, thanks for the input. I hope I don't seem too jaded. ;)

------------------------

Those who dream by day are cognizant of many things which escape those who dream only by night. - Edgar Allan Poe


ionut | June 17, 2008 - 4:04am

Oh, common! 'Stealing someone else's work is just as much a crime as stealing his/her wallet.' How can you say that? Extending what you said, stealing someone's wallet is just as much a crime as murder or a beating. It's frustrating, I know, but I don't agree with you.
----
fake diploma

Pussy Willow | June 17, 2008 - 5:58am

Stealing is stealing, no matter what you steal. If you steal someone else's work you have stolen their avenue of employment, the way they make money - so, yes, "stealing someone's work is just as much a crime as stealing his/her wallet." Stealing, murder and assault are all crimes - period. The degree of punishment is varied on these crimes, for many reasons, but they are all crimes and must not be tolerated.

Plagiarism is stealing. Plain and simple.

The Willow Does Gary Oldman


Sassys | July 2, 2008 - 5:04am

http://bloggerparty.com/blog/sassys

at the end of your comment....it tells me why you don't get this. Duh!

IntricateGirl | June 17, 2008 - 6:38am

I make my living writing. My words are my livelihood. So if you steal them, you steal from me. It cheapens the value of those words, and in some cases, can make it impossible for me to sell articles in the future.

You would not dream of walking into a store, and taking money from the register. Why not?? Because they have an actual product. But what if you have a service performed? What if you get a manicure, or a repairman fixes your washing machine? What if you refuse to pay them? You are stealing, and they would be right to call the cops. People fail to realize that plagiarism is just as much stealing as if you do not pay for services you order.

Obviously, if you are taking the words and using them as your own, you've determined that they have some value. Otherwise, you wouldn't use them. But you are making a conscious decision to not pay that value. It's theft. Plain and simple.


AdaWakeman | July 2, 2008 - 4:29am

Even Shakespeare has been accused of plagiarism! People who can freely express their ideas in speech and writing don’t worry about it. “Ideas are in the air.” (some inventor like Edison, not sure) We patent what is applied for first, not necessarily who had the idea first. Where I am going with this is that catching word thieves is a fruitless journey, unless they steal verbatim. It is easier to teach folks how to express themselves in their own way; If that goal can be reached, we need not worry, since we’re all so unique, right? My point is we humans are more alike than different,so why nitpick? Just my grumpy opinion. As I get older, I have low tolerance for left-brain dominant linear thinkers; They bore me.
______________________
Ada fake college diploma

Sassys | July 2, 2008 - 5:00am

http://bloggerparty.com/blog/sassys

"Left brain linear thinkers?" Being original because we "humans are all alike" makes it that much harder to be original...when someone steals words from an author they are the lowest of the low....Freedom of speech does not mean freedom to steal, nor is it ok to sorta copy some one else's hard work. My father published over 50 books and had he been copied he would have done something about it...why not at least give the original writer a nod? It's not a hard thing to say "This post or story was originally written by so and so" I too have low tolerance for certain things...one of those things is "Right brain dominant linear morons" They destroy everything that is common sense.

Pussy Willow | July 2, 2008 - 5:58am

Adawakeman, when we talk about plagiarism we are not talking about stealing ideas, we are, in fact, talking about stealing verbatim. As you get older and grumpier you might want to pay closer attention to what is being said and why - it might relieve you of some of your boredom.

The Willow Does Gary Oldman


Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

User login

Who's online

There are currently 4 users and 1554 guests online.

Online users:

  • Pancho Villa
  • ammorton
  • huttriver10
  • IntricateGirl

About Me

Name: Karen
Age: 28
Gender: Female
Location: Ohio

About: I am assistant editor for a technical magazine and a part-time freelance writer. I enjoy writing for different topics and genres, but I mainly write nonfiction articles and currently have a few novels in the works.

my profile
my images


Recent comments

Sponsor

Syndicate

XML feed