Skip navigation.
Home
get paid to blog!

Where Have All the Editors Gone?

Please note: This rant isn't directed at any of my esteemed fellows on this site! It's a general concern over a much larger problem....
*******************

I think I was in college when I first noticed it: the general quality of printed publications has been going downhill for quite some time now. This predates the internet, so I can't lay the blame that direction. No, I have to believe that either ignorance or laziness is at fault. Not a day goes by when I do not see a fracturing of spelling or grammar on some document or sign that is in the public's view. It's really quite sad, because my opinion of the business or the writer plummets precipitously when I see simple errors that should be caught long before the item hits the public eye.

Our local newspaper is full of examples on an almost daily basis. One recent caption on a photo of children walking through snow spoke of them "drudging" along. Homophones are misused routinely. It truly damages credibility when I think that there doesn't seem to be a competent person editing those pieces. It looks for all the world like someone is relying on a spell checker and not proofing by hand before sending the paper to the press.

Even worse were some of the errors that I have seen on printed materials from our local schools. My daughter managed to achieve straight A's one semester, and the school dutifully sent out their congratulatory bumper sticker. When I received it, I called the school to complain. First the secretary and then the principal simply could not understand my concern. Why, they wondered, would I be unhappy about receiving a token to recognize my child's achievement? The bumper sticker read, "My child is a honor student." I was sorely tempted to tell the school officials that "I's so happy my kid's gittin' a ed-ju-ma-ca-tion!!" Sadly, I had the strong feeling that the sarcasm would be completely lost on the audience.

Another day, I visited in the school office, and while waiting for my appointment, chanced to read the school district's mission statement posted on the wall. In this important document, on display in buildings across the town for the world to see, the district proudly touted their commitment to "excellance." When I pointed the error out to the secretary and then to the principal, I was told that I was being too particular. What a message they are sending to the student body!

Maybe I am being too particular. I just know that it's difficult for me to get past the poor grammar or the spelling errors to really give credance to the message. I feel that if the professional responsible doesn't care enough about his or her reputation, then perhaps I don't really want to do business with that person.

And yes, I know that all of us (myself included) allow the occasional error to slip out. I pray that I never slip up like that on a query letter or on a writing assignment, but I suspect that I do once in a while. The difference seems to be that I feel horribly embarrassed when I do something like that, and I am all the more careful to proofread my work before making it public.

***********************
Leave me a comment, and I'll pop in to see your blog!
***********************

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
IntricateGirl's picture

UR2 KEWL! Wanna B

UR2 KEWL! Wanna B BFF??

;)

I agree, although I think the internet hastened the decline in language skills.

o ceallaigh's picture

Blame it on James Thurber ...

... who wrote an absolutely hilarious volume, Ladies and Gentlemen's Guide to Modern English Usage, with outrageous takes on grammar and syntax as presented in a famous book by H. W. Fowler. But you had to know your grammar and syntax to get it.

But then he came up with Here Lies Miss Groby, about a lady who couldn't see the story for the commas.

It's been all downhill from there.

Tottie's picture

I think it must be an international disease.

Yes, it is happening everywhere. Sadly our school children have much lower levels of literacy that when we went to school. It is a known fact that many school teachers can't spell properly - so how can they teach spelling well. Good article. I'd also like to see better spelling and grammar on this site. MMmmm.

Tottie's blog

scary statistics

I've been researching for a grant I'm writing for a literacy organization. The city (South Bend Indiana) has a **42**% level one or level two literacy rate. That means nearly HALF of the adult population cannot read at a level to deal with the complexities of adult life, like tax forms and such. Scary and sad, huh?

o ceallaigh's picture

re: scary statistics

Nationally, among 15-year-olds in 2003, the level is 19%, close to the OECD average. Canada, though, is 10%. Which, if memory serves, is closer to what US levels were in the early 1960s, before the Baby Boomer-inspired gutting of US education (I'm a Boomer).

gom jabbar's picture

Editors...

I couldn't agree with you more. People are too forgiving of poor language and writing skills.

Our local newspaper is full of examples on an almost daily basis.

I don't know how many times I've wanted to mark up a copy of my local newspaper and send it back to them. I doubt it would do any good though.

Good blog!

------------------------------------------

Those who dream by day are cognizant of many things which escape those who dream only by night. - Edgar Allan Poe

Getting info out fast has

Getting info out fast has been more important than getting the correct information out. Frustrating!

*Amy Star*

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.