What If You are Wrong About Hell?

I know that religion is a very touchy subject, especially here. I just wanted to ask a question, something that has been on my mind as of late. What if you are wrong about Hell? What if your belief that Hell does not exist turns out to be wrong?

Think about it: you spend your entire life rejecting the beliefs of Christianity because Christians are hypocrites and the Bible was written by the Catholic church. You think religion is for the weak minded and religious zealots can only think what they are told to think. Then one day you die and it turns out that the Christians were right. What will you do then?

Not trying to force the issue, but think about it.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Nancy J That's right,

Nancy J

That's right, Johnny. If they are correct, then the world is going to go on, in it's pathetic way, forever? But, if we are right, then those unbelievers are going to have lost their chance at something wonderful. That is why we don't give up, we keep trying to help them understand that God loves them and wants them back.

I'd rather go to hell

All I have to say about this is if someone, say a secular humanist, leads what Christians would call a moral, decent life and then dies and uh oh, Hell does exist and is sent there. What kind of god is that? Where people who go through their lives hurting others and doing "sinful" things, only to be forgiven and go to heaven, while a person who does not believe in that specific god leads a life that would otherwise be thought of as a virtuous life, except they are doing it without some threat of Heaven and Hell?

I'd rather go to hell than worship that kind of god.

No need to go to hell

You have written an excellent comment gentle! No need to worry about hell - there is no evidence of hell. It is intended to freighten weak people and sell religion (all religions). Some say that fear of God makes people to behave in a more ethical manner, but when we see the earthyly hell this world has gone through (slave trade, colonialisation, caste system, untouchability, etc.) we cannot say that there is a direct relationship between religion-adherence and ethical behaviour. I am glad that at last I found somebody who is courageous. NO hell can be worse than these earthly hells.

o ceallaigh's picture

re: hell

If, as I believe, God is our metaphor for ethics, for right relationship among humans, then if we are truly and properly "in" with our neighbors and follow truly ethical precepts, then, if there is any sense at all to faith, we will be rewarded for our actions, not our philosophies.

For those who think what you believe is regarded by Jahweh as more important than how, I recommend Isaiah, chapter 58, especially verses 1-12.

God as a metaphor for ethics

The problem is this is unacceptable to most Christians.

TLEstrogen's picture

Bible does not say

Be good and nice and sweet and you'll go to heaven. You must believe or God will spit you out. No if's, ands, or butts about it. Why should he allow you to continuously reject Him, persecute Christians and enter Heaven? At least the murderers, etc. that you referred to have truly repented. Who are you to make that decision? God allows you to decide whether to believe, and holds you accountable for your rejection. Period.

Johnny, I saw this title and knew before I opened it that it was yours.......I'd say that's a good thing!

TLEstrogen

You proved my point.

...

IntricateGirl's picture

Shall I get my "fire

Shall I get my "fire insurance" then just in case? Because that is vastly different from actually believing. Let's say that there is one creator who formed the whole world and said that anyone who believes in him goes to a nice place when they die, and everyone else goes to a really nasty place. Then, when I die, I get there and he says, "Do you believe?" I answer, "No, but I don't like the climate in hell, so I am coming here instead." Chances are high he will answer, "I didn't say you could choose between a nice afterlife and a crappy one. I said you can believe in me or not." In short, it's trying to screw the system, which if one believes in an all-powerful deity, is a dangerous game to play.

And while we are on the topic, for most people, it is far more difficult than saying that they aren't Christian because they think Christians are hypocrites. It's an enormous oversimplification.

And finally, what if you die and discover that Hades is waiting to greet you, but you cannot cross because nobody put the coins on your eyelids? What if you are denied entrance for being unclean since you ate pork? Or what if you find that you have died and been reincarnated as a dung beetle? These are no stranger myths and superstitions than being told that there is one man that has three distinct personalities, who created everything out of nothingness in six days. And yet we think the Greeks are silly for believing that their God had a daughter who popped out of his head fully grown.

o ceallaigh's picture

re: what the Bible says

You must believe or God will spit you out

Because, when these lines were written, God was Head of State as well as Head of the Religion. To reject (the) God(s) of your country was to reject your country. To commit treason. The secular state was unknown. And the idea of a God who ruled everywhere, not just my local neighborhood, was in its infancy (a then-novel and profound concept that the Judeans embraced in response to the Babylonian Exile - Harper-Collins Study Bible).

To say that my parochial God is the only God, rather than that my God is the expression of a Divine Presence that speaks of ethical behavior and community preservation to all peoples, each in their own languages, is to commit humankind to perpetual wars of mutual extermination. Not interested in anything that brings us closer to midnight than we already are.

Maverick's picture

I particularly enjoy

How the billions of people who never got the opportunity to be Christians throughout history are damned to an eternity of hellfire without a second thought.

Also excellent is the misrepresentation of what is in the Bible. Did Jesus say that the only way into heaven was believing in him? Nope. Nice try. If anything, more than once he rejected the notion of gaining entrance into heaven via being pious believers in him rather than just good people.

What do you think his opinion would be of people saying who does and does not get into heaven?

I guess you missed the part

I guess you missed the part of the Bible where Jesus said, "I am the Way, the Truth, and the Life. No man comes to the Father but through Me." If that isn't claiming to be the only way, I don't know what is.

o ceallaigh's picture

re: missing parts

where Jesus said, "I am the Way

Well, there are serious Biblical scholars who argue that these words were not by Jesus but by the author of the Gospel of John, penned half a century after the death of Jesus. The Jesus of Mark (the earliest Gospel) made no such claims, and when others made claims for him he typically said "Tell no one". The fictionalization of a great man's words for his own benefit ("John" was building a congregation) is the action of a Pat Robertson, not a Messiah. And for me, that's a poor foundation for faith.

Are you aware that no one

Are you aware that no one (except you, apparently) takes the Jesus Seminar seriously? The Seminar is made up of so-called scholars who placed marbles in jars to state whether they believed Jesus said something or not. Not exactly a very trustworthy method.

o ceallaigh's picture

re: awareness

no one (except you, apparently) takes the Jesus Seminar seriously?

I'm certainly aware that fundamentalist and evangelist groups do not. But then, the Jesus Seminar challenges the core of their belief systems, so it's no surprise that they get called names.

    NAME, n. The switchblade in a fistfight. My admission that I'm out of arguments, so I'm just going to have to kill you.
      - The New Millenium Devil's Dictionary

Among historians and theologians, including the leaders and members of the church I now attend, it's a different matter. As in all matters of front-line scholarship, there are arguments, sometimes ferocious ones. But (to put this in terms most Americans can understand) the concept that "no one takes them seriously" is not consistent with their levels of book sales.

For those who have not already made up their minds, I think what the Jesus Seminar has to say will prove fascinating. And just like any other area of inquiry, what they have to say has to be balanced against the words, deeds, and studies of others. But I would reckon that few at Bloggerparty had even heard of the Jesus Seminar before your friendly neighborhood killjoy started writing about them.

You might want to read a

You might want to read a book called The Case for Faith. It discusses the nonsense put out by the Jesus Seminar and how useless it is.

You may also want to send your quote there over to your good buddy Maverick. He is pretty good at the name calling.

Nancy J There is no

Nancy J

There is no "eternally burning hellfire." The Bible says that the lost are "consumed". That means burned up....gone....nothing but ashes. No God who is the epitome of LOVE would torture someone for eternity.

Before you throw the verses at me that say, "smoke goes up forever and ever", look at where it says that smoke from Sodom and Gomorah went up forever. That smoke is not burning today. There are other places in the Bible that say "forever and ever", and those events are not occuring today either. If you study the origins of the words used in the text, it simply means until it is gone, out of sight, it is no more.

So please don't accuse God of making people suffer for all eternity. That doctrine was one of them that was added much later, after the original church fathers were all dead.

Destroying the wicked is called "God's strange act." It will break His heart. He loves the lost as much as the saved. That is why He gives them so many chances to change their minds.

There is reason to believe that many people who never heard of Christ but were commandment keepers (loved others more than themselves), will be saved. There are true stories in remote areas of the world where "someone" came to a village and told people that someday someone would come with a great book (Bible), and until then, this is how they should live. God has ways of revealing himself to His people.

Scoff if you will, but someday (soon), "every knee will bend and acknowledge Him." I would rather bend willingly now, then to be forced into it then. How about you?

o ceallaigh's picture

re: eternity

don't accuse God of making people suffer for all eternity. That doctrine was one of them that was added much later

Truth! As I understand it, of course. :)

The Hebrews had little if any conception of an afterlife. Sheol was "the place of the dead", i.e. the grave. King David famously fasted and prayed while one of his sons was sick, but ceased when the child died. "While my child was sick, there was a chance that God would relent and return him to me. Now that he is dead, he will never return to me. So there is no point to fasting." Not the words or deeds of someone who thought there was an afterlife that the actions of the living could affect in any way (an idea that features in much Christian thought and history).

There is also little hint of an afterlife in the Jewish concept of the resurrection from the dead, as it was understood in the days before Jesus of Nazareth. This was a physical resurrection of bodies - which presumably had been lying in the ground doing nothing all this time.

Later Jewish writings did deal with the concept of an afterlife - probably (I forget the source for this item) after contact between the Jewish and Greek states, especially after the conquest of the Middle East by Alexander the Great. It was in that context that the word Gehenna, which the Greeks translated as Hades, started to appear. A word derived from Valley of Hinnom, according to some scholars. The Valley of Hinnom was Jerusalem's trash dump, continually on fire. Hmmm...

Maverick's picture

I think you're a wacko

I hope you remember this conversation on your death bed. Particularly the "(soon)" part.

It's all about the relationship

You can't get to heaven through works, but through a personal relationship with God. The only way to heaven is to profess that you are a believer. Too many people get tied up in the rules, but it really is so much simpler than that. Just believe. That's it. God cares about our hearts and souls, not our works. We can't overanalyze what God is all about, but he is a loving God that will save you from eternity in hell. All you need is to believe. Heaven is a gift, free for the asking.

o ceallaigh's picture

About that relationship ...

Rabbi Harry Kemelman, speaking through his fictional amateur sleuth Rabbi David Small in Wednesday the Rabbi Got Wet, which is a discourse on Judaism disguised as a mystery novel, said (I paraphrase, the book isn't in front of me) "Faith in the Christian sense is impossible, because God is by definition unknowable ..."

I think this is an excellent point. If God is truly omnipotent, omniscient, omnipresent, who the hell do we think we are, claiming that we can have any kind of relationship with this Entity? As James Blish had Scotty say in a Star Trek story he wrote for his "Classic Episodes" synopsis series, such a though is "like sticking a 10-ampere tap into God". To think so turns Christianity into a mystical religion. Bring on the incense. Kemelman rejects it: "Ours is a system of ethical conduct."

Kemelman also relates "it's hard being a Jew." Precisely, I think, because of that ethical system. Because, if I have this down right, the practicing Jew does have to think about that ethical system and how to behave in it. Kemelman relates rabbinical discussions on ethical dilemmas, on which the final decision was "set it aside until the return of the prophet Elijah".

Compared to this, the yoke of Jesus is indeed easy. Instead of a complex and evolving legal code, the misapplication of which features prominently in the books of the prophets and in the Gospels, you have a man-God, a Hercules (I make no apology for the comparison), telling believers what to do. It's always easier to use a recipe than to cook from scratch. It's ... heaven. And the other is ... hell ... Assuming of course that the one who wrote the recipe can cook. Or that those to whom he gives the recipe can read.

No one has come to earth to

No one has come to earth to tell us what is after death. But those who were granted a vision know it . One would rather suffer any deal upon this earth than to pass a second in hell. Darkness cannot withstand light. it is an experience. For argument, each ne is free to believe or not

Who is sure not to be

Who is sure not to be hypocrite at least in some moments of his life? We who argu can we......

MommyWriter's picture

Yep - I good question...

Check out my post here - I asked something simialr:
InsideMyHead

lisalogan's picture

Or What If...

The REASON everyone's big Backstage Pass into Heaven supposedly hinges upon BELIEF is that God cannot exist without it? Why else would human belief be demanded over and above all else, even good, honest deeds? What society could possibly function under such a system?

Of course, we could be good and do everything God says, and we'll be spared, right? Oh, wait, there was JOB, God's mostest bestest faithfulest servant, who was tortured beyond all reason thanks to a series of BETS when God and the Devil were sitting around the throne room one day. Can you imagine the news headlines if someone's dad bet a psycho that his kid woudn't flinch if he burned him with a lighter?? Wake up and smell the brimstone, folks...it's already here.

Janell
Drive Traffic to your Blog FREE with Traffic Swarm and Blog Explosion!

o ceallaigh's picture

To quote copyrighted Tammy ...

.... hoohoohoohahahahaheheeheeHOWWOOOOOOOLL!!!!

This place is a bad influence on me.

Of course you realize you've just hacked off a world full of priests, imams, deacons, Levites, ministers, rabbis, cantors, ayatollahs, (big sucking noise) popes, metropolitans, witch doctors and TV preachers. All of whom feed at the Trough of the Celestial Domain. And, in your world, would all have to find real jobs.

Then again, Si Dieu n'existait pas, il faudrait l'inventer. ("If God did not exist, we would have to invent him". Which Voltaire never said. He spoke French.) Cue Dr. Phil and the crowd of psychoanalysts he figureheads. With their pills and their big bills. Umm ...

I am Tammy©'s picture

hahaha~

that made me laugh right the hell out loud. copyrighted tammy. lol

rawralphadawg's picture

Ignorance

I think most of the arguements in here contain a lot of ignorance. People have obviously not done the research, on both sides. I'm a Christian, believe in Hell, believe that the post written is as true as it gets. I'm not going to fight about. Someone said to read The Case for Faith, and I would agree. That author has 3 books that are honesty about the most unbiased pro-Christian books out there. He wasn't a Christian while he wrote The Case for Christ, and he traveled all over the country in search of the truth. He brought every argument against Christianity and God that any of you could come up with, and he got answers from various sources. It might actually be worth checking out instead of being rude about a subject you obviously don't know a lot about.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.