Is Atheism a Religion?

The Geminian's picture
ATHEISM | God | Religion | The Geminian | Theism

The Geminian offers this spiel:

Is Atheism a Religion? A simple question, In order to answer the question, we must be sure we understand the question.

What is Atheism? A precise and undebatable definition of Atheism is required in order to move forward, so let us define it.

The word Atheism can be broken down easily in two parts: A-, and Theism. The first part, A-, is a prefix meaning "not" or the absence of, without, lacking. The second part, Theism, means a belief in the existence of a god or gods. Conjoined, the word Atheism means:

A lack of belief in the existence of a god or gods.

The word religion comes from the Latin word religio, which means: the service and worship of God or the supernatural ; a cause, principle, or system of beliefs held to with ardor and faith

Is Atheism a religion?

Let us superimpose our definitions unto the question.

Is Atheism, (the lack of a belief in the existence of a god or gods,) a religion, (the service and worship of a god or supernatural?)

There is an obvious contradiction here.

Can one who lacks a belief in any god(s) existence, serve, worship, or have faith in a god?

The answer is no. Atheism is not a religion. Religion implies theism, it requires it. Theism does not imply religion, as one may have the belief but not serve or worship.

To say that atheism is a religion is also to say that all humanity has a religion. The word Theism applies only to humans, Atheism, by definition applies to anything that doesn't believe. An Aardvark lacks a belief in a god or gods, but does it have a religion?

To say Atheism is a "belief system" is a contradiction, as belief system requires belief, and atheism is the absence of belief.

Part of the confusion may come from the chronology of the two words: Theism and Atheism. Theism was defined first, later the prefix A, was added to create a new word. This chronology creates confusion in that the word atheism sprang from the word theism, but in fact, historically, theism sprang from atheism. Error occurs when one supposes that atheism is a choice, a choice is an active assertion, this is not the case, to believe is active. Theism is an assertion by an individual, it is a choice, one must subscribe to a belief. Atheism requires nothing, no choice, no assertion. Every baby born is an atheist, they lack the belief, later they make a conscious choice to begin to believe,(this includes Jesus.) Is is ironic that theists look upon atheists as "dissidents," because it is the theists who broke ranks and distanced themselves from atheists, this is also required of each individual theist at least once.

Atheism is not a religion.
Theism is dissention from the norm.

These two assertions are inarguable.

The Geminian

The Bible

Is Jesus The Anti-Christ?

On Evolution, God, and Alpha-Geminians

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
IntricateGirl's picture

I agree that atheism is not

I agree that atheism is not a religion, however I disagree that it is not a belief system. Atheists BELIEVE that there is no god. However, I'm not sure it matters anyway. When someone asks an atheist what their religion is, and the atheist responds, they are not saying that because they are misguided about what the word "religion" means. They are doing it for the sake of time. Rather than standing there explaining that they do not have a religion, and being mistaken for someone who is simply undeclared, they use the label of religion to save time.

Visit my site!!

The Geminian's picture

undeclared, I love that!

I am going to use that, with your graces. However, just to clarify, I believe that there are no trolls. So the word troll has no meaning, as they do not exist. I cannot prove this fact, as there is no evidence for me to present.. This illustrates the fact that one cannot prove a negative. And, without proof to provide some constraint to the idea (trolls are hairy) any other idea (trolls are environmentally friendly) can be associated with it and not violate the rules of the concept.

You are right about saving time, I do it to, now I will say I am "undeclared".

Love me

More of The Geminian!!

Are We STILL "Home of the Brave?"

IntricateGirl's picture

Feel free to use the term.

Feel free to use the term. :)

The problem is, the word almost MUST become defined because you used it. The words "troll" and "God" have been defined. The problem only comes about when you debate over the meaning.

When I say the word troll, everyone automatically jumps to their own conclusion of what constitutes a troll. By saying you don't believe in trolls, you've already got your own idea of what that means, and are declaring an anti-belief in that. Same with God. Even though a Hindu may define "God" in a very different way than a Christian, an atheist says that there is not a single definition of the word they accept.

Let's go one step further. I tell you right now that I do not believe in snargleflegs. I know that a lot of people may believe in snargleflegs, but I reject the idea of it. Whether you actually ask it or not, your first thought is probably, "What's a snarglefleg?" You didn't ask that about a troll or God, right?? Because there's a more or less accepted definition in place already. And even if you don't believe in it, you understand what others are talking about when they say it. By saying you don't believe in trolls or in God, you are saying that you have at least a basic understanding of what they mean, but you reject the idea that they exist. It's not trying to prove a negative, it's understanding a definition and denying the existence. But snargleflegs are different. Until I define it, I could be talking about anything. There is no information to make an informed decision on the subject.

Visit my site!!

The Geminian's picture

Snargleflegs!!

Very nicely put IntricateGirl!!

Snargeleflegs have have deepened my understanding of both God and trolls, as well as the importance of having a universal term as a response to religious inquires.

More of The Geminian!!

Are We STILL "Home of the Brave?"

James24's picture

Atheism may not be a religion;

it is certainly a creed and it can be pursued in a zealous way just like any religion or ideology.

The Lionheart's Den

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.