Here's why state-mandated physical education sucks.

An Open Letter to the Physical Education Department:
Ladies and gentlemen, we have a problem. This is something often said in connotation with the United States of America, world-renowned for its many problems and its government’s consistent attempts to hide behind past heroism instead of acknowledging aforementioned problems. The problem presently in question, however, has never come up overseas and likely not even in Congress in the last twenty years — the problem of federally mandated physical education.

Look at it this way. The United States of America is the most obese nation in the world. Since a mandatory physical education program in all public schools was added, have these numbers begun to go down? No. Actually, they’ve gone up. Part of the reason supported by nutritionists is increased stress.

Now, let’s take an example such as, say, kleptomania. Never in my own life did I think I’d be able to comprehend how a kleptomaniac feels — obviously stealing is bad, and they know it. Yet the kleptomaniac, when in front of an opportune situation, has the short moral dilemma — do I do what is right, or what feels right? In the end, despite best moral intentions “what feels right� wins. And for some, the worst thing going on in their lives could easily be cited to be the hullabaloo about physical education. I am aware that readers of this rant will want to ay it’s only me. It’s not. There are other people who find extended physical activity to be the worst forms of torture. Few, maybe, especially in a sports-filled community such as this one, but those people do exist.

Physical education has become, for me personally, a form of both physical and psychological torture. When put in a situation where there must be gym class had, I feel absolutely nothing but sheer terror. This began when we moved to Westchester, and suddenly gym was mandatory. At six years old it horrified me. At seventeen it is my worst enemy.

The motions they put you through — anything from sit-ups to running to playing any sort of sport — are like poison to me. Fitness activities are my kryptonite, and competitive sports? For a half-blind, clumsy, gangly, easily breakable girl? That’s just an instant-acting lethal injection to add to all of the previous sharp and pained metaphors previously stated.

And so, when the chance came to get away from it, even just for an hour, I happily took it. Look, I can leave PE and not go back, and no one will notice. Just the once. It’s been just the once for three years, now, and I can quite honestly tell you that every single time I say never again, I mean it. There’s no skipping for the sake of skipping. There’s approaching the class and simply just breaking. There’s a nagging fear that says go, get away, don’t come back here. You’ve done it before, you can do it again, you’ll fix it later.

I’m also a hydrophobe, and by that I do not mean I’m rabid, I mean I have a subconscious fear of water so thick that washing my hands makes my stomach lurch. That sounds pretty debilitating, huh? I can also tell you,s traight forward, that I would gladly spend an hour and a half in a near-freezing lake, scaring myself near to death, if I never had to go near a physical education class ever again.

It does not build character, it builds shame. My family has expressed an inability to look at me when I bring up the subject. It does not make every person more physically fit, because involved in fitness classes, I will almost invariably drop in caloric level. At 84 pounds, this isn’t at all healthy. There’s no contribution. I, in fact, am much more likely to be irreparably damaged in a gym class due to the fact that there’s little weight I can lift and no sport whatsoever that I can play properly, than I am to have positive physical changes made.

After fitness classes, I can’t feel my feet, and my hands are freezing. After any sport, I’m near tears from the constant, neverending mocking, both out loud and in silent glances, over my degree of incompetence with athletics. And after any class, my heart is pounding out of my ribcage, and I’m gasping for air.

That last part? That sounds like before gym classes, too — when the panic attacks hit. The ones that say, quietly, temptingly, you’ve done it before, you can do it again. And I’m afraid, I’m sick and scared and hating it so much, and I listen to it.

That’s just my story. I can name plenty of other stories. Do you, Mamaroneck High School, want to be known for racism? Of course not. How about the taunting of people not at average weight? Gee, I’d think not. So, let’s take a look at what the school did this year. Nowhere is it listed on any state or federal law, but hey, all students without a proper medical excuse have to run and do calisthenics before class, period!

Which leads to the terrible mocking of the too-skinny kids, the obese kids, and just about anyone who can’t make it twice around the track in three minutes at a run. Believe it or not, gym teachers, if you look past your perfect little sports kings and queens that you’ve raised to be just what you want, there are people who are not fit and won’t become so with your calisthenics and your running and your sports classes. People with anorexia, hypothyroid, diabetes — people with pituitary issues, with natural limps, with terrible asthma, with other metabolic problems, and people with depression, people with panic anxiety, people with autism, people with ADD, people with bipolar.

Those people? You’re hurting those people.

You’re hurting the chances of possibly talented people, because they’re stuck in their place due to a terrible undeniable fear of physical education. You’ve probably never suffered from such panic as these students suffer from, and you probably don’t know what it means to not have control of your own reaction. Maybe when it comes to drugs or drinking, I bet, but I give you another newsflash — the people you’re inflicting such hurt on don’t do any of those things.

That’s what your perfect sports stars are doing in their spare time.

These kids are reading, writing, creating. Sure, they watch TV and play video games and pig out on ice cream, but sports don’t matter. Many of them don’t go to parties, and what’s at parties? Drugs. These are the people who are in no way hurting their own bodies through means that they can control. Something’s hurting their minds, though, physical education department.

And it’s you.

Posted in pseudelight's blog | delicious | digg | reddit | 402 reads

Submitted by pseudelight on February 17, 2006 - 11:05am.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Miss Lissa | February 17, 2006 - 12:38pm

Listen, there are going to be plenty of things in life that make you want to vomit, but that you have to do anyway. That's part of growing up. Physical education may not seem important to you, art class may not seem important to someone else, and still another may hate going to math class. I am sure that there are many kids at your school who experience panic attacks and sheer horror at the though of Calculus, but you gotta do what you gotta do, bottom line.

I'm sure that it is all as horrbile for you as you make it seem, but at the same time, it is not fair for you to characterize the other kids, who do excel in sports, as those who are using drugs and partying. That's just as unfair as people judging you because you can't play sports.

One other thing: how is phys ed "hurting the chances of possibly talented people"? The sad (to you) fact is that physical education is as much a part of a well rounded education as are drama and art and music, and whatever else you are into.

Once you get to college, and especially when you enter into the workforce, you are in for a rude awakening. There are going to be tasks that you have to perform, classes that you have to go to, etc, that you are going to hate. And you are not going to be coddled, and a medical excuse is not going to get you out of it. So now is as good a time as any for you to learn to "suck it up" and do what you have to do.

Sorry I can't be more sympathetic, I just don't want you running around with the notion that you are going to be able to avoid things or complain them out of existence for the rest of your life....we all wish that were true, it's just not.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

User login

Who's online

There are currently 5 users and 2261 guests online.

Online users:

  • xThvBQtfbAeXy
  • aquarium
  • insuranceclub
  • ms zola
  • IntricateGirl

About Me

Name: Rue
Gender: Female
Location: New York

my profile
my images


Recent comments

Sponsor

Syndicate

XML feed