Maverick's picture

Do You Come From A School Of Thought

Or a school of told?

Hi, I'd like to introduce myself. You can call me Mav.

It's a pleasure.

Sorry to cut the chit-chat so short, but I have a serious question.

I guess I can preface it a little bit... since we hardly know eachother and I want to make sure you really understand what I'm asking.

I come from a school of thought where thinking is a requirement.

Preferably, this thinking is independent.

Now, let me clarify that a tiny bit. Obviously, it takes some thought to assimilate an idea and apply it to unique situations. But, the idea itself was not independently arrived at and therefore the thinking is not independent.

I'll use an analogy that hopefully is painful enough a memory as to stick for most people.

I assume most people took geometry at some point in life.

And most people who took geometry hopefully remember doing proofs.

And, hopefully, if I mention "Side-Angle-Side" in reference to geometry proofs some people would say "aha!"

In geometry, SAS is a useful tool for proving two triangles congruent. You can hardly avoid it and manage a passing grade.

But, SAS is just a short cut. It has its own proof.

And it is the proof of SAS that requires original thought, not the use of the short-cut, however valid (and in this case there's even proof!)

So, do you come from the school of thought whose members understand why SAS works?

Or, do you just accept it because the teacher told your class that you could use it?

What if your teacher was confused and told you "Angle-Side-Side" instead?

Sorry, did I just call you an ASS?

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Hahaha

This made me laugh out loud, even though I don't remember geometry one bit!

o ceallaigh's picture

re: school of thought

Not sure I'm laughing.

After a lifetime in a profession that (says here right on the cover) is all about independent thought (and discovering there's less of it there than is claimed), I've learned both to practice it and to value it. But I've also learned that you can't really do it unless you bring your own money.

Or haven't you yet worked out that Darwin could only get away with the Origin of Species because he had his own inherited fortune, and married into another?

Or that Bill Gates could only afford to tinker with his computer toys in the garage because his Daddy was a rich physician and could afford it - not to mention the lifelong modelling of "success" he performed for his son?

No, milad, thinking is overrated. Ask all the Palestinian Ph.D.s in concentration camps. The profit is in doing what you are told. In believing and following. All the way to the grave, Master Salesman Willi Loman. Straight to Armageddon, Heinie. George. Sieg Heil.

lol

I try to not even be from a school.

From The Wig

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.