America's Next Top Model Goes Beyond Trainwreckage

ModelMom's picture

Oh man, where do I start on this one.....

Well, ashamed as I should be to admit it, I do take in all of the reality (reality my ass) shows that have to do with the modeling world. Perhaps I'm attracted to this offal because I've been a part of the Industry for over 8 years now and I'm apparently also a glutton for punishment. So it is what it is, and I shouldn't complain about how AWFUL ANTM is, but I am gonna rant about it because why the heck not?!

As a quick side note I want to say that "The Agency" on VH1 and Petra Nemcova's "A Model Life" on TLC were really good modeling based reality shows that were pretty damned realistic and the models in it were actually capable of making very good careers for themselves. They were young, tall, thin and beautiful (some conventional, some exotic, some quirky). Perfect fodder for fashion. ANTM on
the other hand has never really quite been great at picking "true" models. They have had very attractive girls on the show, but "attractive"and "modelesque" are two very different things.

In fashion modeling, beauty is all about proportion or all about shock factor. But even the quirkiest girls are fascinating to look at in their androgeny. The girls Tyra picks (with the exception of a few that really could model and subsequently get booted off the show....WTF?) could be perfect news anchors, men's mag girls, or pageant queens....but top fashion models...I beg to differ. This season in particular is hard for me to watch. These are the best girls you could find in the ENTIRE United States? Have mercy.

Only Lisa has any undeniable model potential. Heather is hailed as the quirky beauty and indeed she has a very high fashion look but her personality suffers due to the fact that she has Asperger's Syndrome (and God bless her for going out there and attacking this competition with all her might) but in reality the modeling industry would eat her alive. It is a sink or swim industry without exception. She could win the competition but would she be able to handle it thereafter?

Victoria, the Yale girl, is adorable, also has a great fashion face but her body is not modelesque. Mila, who got kicked off tonight, also had a very oddly pear shaped body which in the real world would be viewed as completely healthy and normal, but for high fashion (okay...I know I am gonna get crucified here) she is (aaaaaaah, am I really gonna say this? ) fat. Big legs, hips and thighs.....not good for modeling especially since they weren't pointing her out as the plus sized girl. They actually never mentioned her weight on the show, perhaps because now it is taboo? Oh, and by fat, I mean "fat for modeling". Sorry, but that is what it is too. I've lived and breathed this industry and been called everything from ethereal to fat assed all in the same day. Seriously.

I in no way am a proponent of models looking like heroin junkies, but high fashion has always used very thin girls as models because the models are in essence just hangers for the couture. Having a J. Lo booty is just not gonna get you a booking with Versace. Believe me. I got sent home from Tokyo for having a big ass.....my hips measured 34.5. The general public may want modeling to be all about looking like a real woman, but that really isn't what the industry is about. Fashion, especially high fashion, is about selling a fantasy. Rail thin, pre pubescent girls without stretchmarks, cellulite or acne (and mainly from Brazil and Eastern Europe....I guess the gene pools there are quite incredible) are a fantasy....so that is why they become top models. Tyra's show is something of a circus side show. I'm not really sure what she is doing....but nothing about the show....and I mean NOTHING is reality based when it comes to modeling.

I just had to put my 2 cents in on this one. Just watched the 2nd episode....and have been rolling my eyes about it so I thought I'd sit and spit out some words then go read a book and re-smart myself. Ha!

Speaking of smart.....VH1 is gonna be airing "America's Most Smartest Model" soon. Also a reality competition....and yes I will be watching it so that I can sit perplexed and pissed at the awful name the competitors will be giving the rest of American models. Thanks guys. Thanks a freakin lot.

ModelMom – September 26, 2007 – 8:39pm

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

I almost agree...

IntricateGirl's picture

"Victoria, the Yale girl, is adorable, also has a great fashion face but her body is not modelesque. Mila, who got kicked off tonight, also had a very oddly pear shaped body which in the real world would be viewed as completely healthy and normal, but for high fashion (okay...I know I am gonna get crucified here) she is (aaaaaaah, am I really gonna say this? ) fat. Big legs, hips and thighs.....not good for modeling especially since they weren't pointing her out as the plus sized girl. They actually never mentioned her weight on the show, perhaps because now it is taboo? Oh, and by fat, I mean "fat for modeling". Sorry, but that is what it is too. I've lived and breathed this industry and been called everything from ethereal to fat assed all in the same day. Seriously."

The truth is, you're absolutely right. I go through runway fashion pics at a rate of about 25 a week. The average collection has 35-50 pieces, and only a handful are worth discussing, but I still have to go through the whole collection. So this whittles it down to about two to three designers a week, spread over the 6 month fashion season. In other words, I look at a lot of these damn photos. And yes, the girls are thin and exotic. They have to be. I saw one just this week from Gwen Stefani's L.A.M.B. line. The girl looked like she had some MASSIVE thighs. If I keep this in context of the runway, she did! That girl was too thick to be on the runway. If I compare her to my own body, it sounds like a stupid statement to make. I mean, that girl's thighs are AT LEAST half the size of mine. Where in the hell do I get off calling her fat?! But view both together. If this outfit made this child, and I do mean child, look like she had large thighs, how freakin' ugly is that outfit going to look on me?! I'm totally doomed!! I wouldn't even consider buying it because I know that it's going to look bad on me. In that case, fashion has failed. It's telling me that I cannot be beautiful. :S So, no. I'm not going to crucify you for that. I get it.

BUT, "my hips measured 34.5". Alright. Now THAT'S crucifixion worthy!! ;) :D In my next life, I'm certain that I'll have a perfect body, but I won't be the least bit interested in fashion. lol

Visit my site!!

IntricateGirl – September 27, 2007 – 5:18am

thanks IntricateGirl!

ModelMom's picture

i actually knew you would totally get where i was coming from since you are into fashion, etc. i think that the general population gets up in arms when it comes to stuff like this.....and lately there seem to be some newbies on here that are a little defensive about just about everything everyone posts....so i was prepping myself for an attack and comments about how people like me propagate bulimia and anorexia epidemics.

i've been at both ends of the industry. and it is a mind fuck and not for the weak. and its not like i've handled rejection and nasty comments like a trooper. i've had plenty of meltdowns and self confidence issues because of it. luckily i am too lazy to have gone crazy at the gym working out hours on end and too muchof a glutton to have taken up starvation. i am on the shorter end of the modeling spectrum at 5'7" (which i should never admit to seeing as i am always marketed as 5'8") and have never been a waif. thin, yes, but not bony. hmmm....guess that i've never had issues getting work although i also never made it to the top (hence, middle model...ha!) but getting to the top also many times requires extracurricular activites with photogs and/or clients....and i am not into that load of crap. in the beginning of my career i also had issues with the owner of my mother agency not thinking i could travel because i was, in his opinion, too short. then i proved him wrong. but it is easier for shorter girls who photograph tall to work then it is for a thicker girl to work regular fashion (instead of plus).

i'll have to check out the girl in the LAMB collection you are talking about but i know i will agree with you! i am sure she is tiny by normal standards but the average runway model is 5"10" and weighs 110 lbs.....so compared to girls like that anyone would be hard put to look portly! ha!

and to be honest, even though i know my perception of the perfect body has been tainted by industry standards, i still dont find the really waify girls attractive. breastbones and sunken cheeks are just not my vision of beauty. my husband thinks those girls look like praying mantises (ha! my favorite bug! eeech!) the girls that i think are drop dead are the victoria's secret type girls. they are still thin but with some tone and shape. watching that fashion show is a totaly practice in masochism. i cant help but start comparing and well, there aint no way in hell this ol mom of two will ever have an ass that sits up on her shoulders and the boobs to match! LOL!

and yeah....the hip thing was a total mind f***. i left tokyo with a complex that is for sure.

Airing my dirty laundry at: Peacocks on Leashes

Humor Blog<br />
Top Sites

ModelMom – September 27, 2007 – 7:55am

The L.A.M.B. model

IntricateGirl's picture

is wearing a black jacket that looks like a flight attendant uniform, and a pair of capri workout pants. It's not a good look.

I think everyone just assumes that models are ALL anorexic and bulimic. And frankly, that's pretty stupid. Obviously, it's a really cutthroat business, and the ones who are going to really succeed are going to have the figure naturally. I liken it to a football player. If you're going to be a linebacker, sure, *maybe* you could succeed if you started out a 98lb weakling, but more likely, you need to be a pretty big boy to start with.

As far as causing eating disorders, it's so difficult to say. Everyone reads my fashion blog and sees that I'm trying to lose weight, and I think they assume that I must be doing it in an unhealthy way. And the complete opposite is true. I will never be a size 0. I doubt I'll even be a size 6. It's not appropriate for my body type and shape. But when I get to a size 10, I'm going to be rocking it even better than Marilyn Monroe did. lol

Yeah. Those Victoria's secret girl's are gorgeous. I hate them all. :D I totally avoid that show because it's torture. I wouldn't mind actually going to the show though. I'd sit in the front row and flick quarters off their butts. lol

Visit my site!!

IntricateGirl – September 27, 2007 – 8:32am

I have watched this show

ammorton's picture

it's hard for me to get into it- I like fashion, but dont know much about modeling. I do agree with the look they want and go for. I don't like it. You seem like a very small frame of a girl, cant believe they said you had a big butt. It seems to me that it is a very hard business. Was your experience a good one?

ammorton – September 27, 2007 – 3:09pm

i was pretty shocked too!

ModelMom's picture

i mean, i knew that i had a butt compared to the pancakes most of the girls had in japan and tokyo is notorious for wanting rail thin models. but to be told that 34.5 was fat and that i needed to loose 2 inches in a week was beyond comprehension for me....not to mention totally unrealistic. so i went home. overall its been an awesome experience for me with a few glitches here and there but i started older than most and knew what i wanted to get out of it which was a lot of traveling. so i got what i wanted! enough to start my peacocks blog! LOL! anyways, you arent missing out on anything by skipping out on ANTM. it is crap and nothing at all having to do with the real modeling world...or even real fashion, shoots, etc.

Airing my dirty laundry at: Peacocks on Leashes

Humor Blog<br />
Top Sites

ModelMom – September 27, 2007 – 4:13pm

As much as I like Tyra-

ammorton's picture

I cant help but think it's just another way to make some money and call it a reality show. It gets ratings, or it wouldn't be back on. You are better off with out all that stuff to deal with. I am sure there are other modeling jobs you can do that will be alot more complimenting for you anyway. Like you said, you got to do some awesome traveling. That in itself was worth it, huh.

ammorton – September 27, 2007 – 5:02pm

To Be Fair, Ammorton,...

Catfish's picture

that's exactly what it's supposed to be. This show is the one that allowed her to pursue the talk show. And, I have to say that I watched the first season, and the young lady who won that competition was extremely pretty, and has gone on to other things, including magazine covers and, I think she's been on a couple of TV shows. After that, it seems like they're just digging for people who will make the show interesting instead of someone who could actually be a model, and I stopped watching because I don't find any of these people interesting, the different shoots interesting, and why the heck is Janice still on this show? I understand modeling is a tough business, not as glamorous as many young girls think it is, but it can't be as mean and vicious as this Janice woman is. Plus, someone as scary looking as she is now has some nerve telling someone else they're not pretty enough.

Reviews of Everything, reviews and opinions of, well, almost anything!

Catfish – September 27, 2007 – 6:04pm

your right catfish

ammorton's picture

I did happen to catch the winner of the first show and she was pretty.
As for Janice-um...what is with her? She is the Simon Cowell of this show. Only I think she is alot worse. And no, she isn't that pretty.

ammorton – September 28, 2007 – 3:15am

the runner up was better!

ModelMom's picture

if i am remembering the right season, elyse sewell was the runner up and truly possesed model qualities (plus she was really smart). i wasn't crazy about adrienne who won. she went on to marry one of the "brady's" and appeared on that god awful VH1 reality series "the surreal world". she's trashy. i wasnt impressed. elyse on the other hand has gone on to travel extensively as a model and as a fantastic and witty blog on livejournal about her experiences. and oddly enough she now lives in portland and is repped by my agency. small world.

Airing my dirty laundry at: Peacocks on Leashes

Humor Blog<br />
Top Sites

ModelMom – September 28, 2007 – 8:32am

i'm a sucker ammorton!

ModelMom's picture

because i still watch this crap! LOLOL! tyra gets ratings from people who watch and really want to be models and think this is the real deal, people who just cant find their remote and get stuck on her channel and people like me that like to suffer through really bad tv. :-P

Airing my dirty laundry at: Peacocks on Leashes

Humor Blog<br />
Top Sites

ModelMom – September 27, 2007 – 7:34pm

Why our Catfish, you almost sound like you watch the show :)!

Aha! So that is what you do in your spare time!

Inquest of a Woman – September 27, 2007 – 6:07pm

I did admit, IOAW,...

Catfish's picture

that I watched the first season with some fascination. Now, every once in awhile I'm turning the channel and it pops up on MTV, and I stop to see what the models look like before I move on. Hey, I'm a big Tyra Banks fan; hot! lol

Reviews of Everything, reviews and opinions of, well, almost anything!

Catfish – September 27, 2007 – 6:48pm

LOL catfish! Janice scares me!

ModelMom's picture

janice truly is scary. if she gets one more face lift her nose will end up on top of her head! she really has some nerve cutting down the girls in past seasons (she's been replaced by twiggy as a judge) but she is pretty right on in her opinions on a lot of the girls as brutal as it may be. the industry is cut throat beyond words. and if a model makes it through without fitting 99% of the industry standards it is usually because she is well connected. the thing is that clients will normally not talk like that in front of you but what is heard as soon as a girl leaves the room is brutal....i've caught several conversations like that about other girls while waiting for my turn.

you know, the clients least likely to say anything will be the worst in judging a girl. the clients that have thought i needed to lose weight have not been many, but the few that have had that opinion were definitely on the overweight spectrum of things. the make-up artists that have scoffed at my having A pimple have had zits or acne scars, and the casting director in milan who said i had ugly hair looked like her deranged poodle had nested on top of her own dome.

the last bad experience i had like this was in portland a few months ago. i was doing a benefit fashion show as a favor for my agent and one of the designers developed major attitude with me on the day of the fitting telling me i was too skinny! WTF?!?! i had had my baby just 3 months prior so believe me, i have been skinnier. then she took my comp card and told me i looked tired in person. i bit my tongue but wanted to scream "ok bitch, NO ONE looks as good as they do in their comps in person. it is smoke & mirrors, modeling is in and of itself an illusion, fantasy, magic. and i am doing this freakin show for FREE so quit your crap!" and yes i may have looked a bit tired, my daughter was still a newborn. on the night of the show as we are rushing backstage from rolling rack to rolling rack for the next outfit to use on the runway i couldnt find mine on her rack. she strolls up to me with a smirk and tells me that she didnt want me in her dress.. and she was wearing the dress herself! and believe me, she is a far from attractive woman by any standards. (insiders like to call people like her model haters).

so yeah, it hurts, it sucks but it can also be glorious. the good clients make up for the bad, the money and travel opps are bar none, getting to live the lifestyle is definitely worth taking some abuse for (ha!)....like i said, i started older so i think i've handled things better than maybe a girl who starts at 14 would. but no matter what it is a mind trip to hear that you are too short, too skinny, too fat, too white, too tan, too ethnic, not ethnic enough, too freckled, not freckled enough, and the list goes on.....on a daily basis. thank god i never had anyone like janice scream this kind of stuff in may face though!

ok, i am tired, long day, so am probably rambling at this point. suffice it to say that tyra's show is the jerry springer show of modeling reality TV. all fluff and shock value.

and let me take this opp to shamelessly advertise my modeling blog.....Peacocks on Leashes....the link is below this sentence somewhere.....if you go back to my first entries and read through to my last post it gives a real account of life as a fashion model. i'm only a quarter of the way through it....have been slacking on writing there lately.....but all of this model talk is getting me inspired to get caught up! :-D

Airing my dirty laundry at: Peacocks on Leashes

Humor Blog<br />
Top Sites

ModelMom – September 27, 2007 – 7:32pm

Amazing, Model Mom

Catfish's picture

my wife is with a modeling agency herself, but these people have been nothing but nice to her. She didn't come in as a child, and the woman recruited her after seeing her at the state fair. She hasn't done a lot of shoots, which suits her fine since she's got a regular job and does many other types of projects on the side, but she's flattered whenever she's asked to do a shoot, and that's all that counts. But I have to say that if I ever heard that someone was mean to her,... well, consequences, if you know what I mean. ;-)

Reviews of Everything, reviews and opinions of, well, almost anything!

Catfish – September 27, 2007 – 7:40pm

you're a good husband catfish!

ModelMom's picture

my husband gets so mad when he hears these stories. but most of them are in my pre marriage past with the exception of the portland fashion show. he was up in arms about that one and told me he was going to talk to my agent about that awful client.....give a piece of his mind....but i stopped him because this is such a small market that i cant afford to burn any bridges.

most clients and agents i have worked with have been great but there are bad apples and i have met my bunch. you tend to run into the negative when you work in this industry full-time. your wife is lucky that she has had good experiences and i'm sure she will continue to do well and have positive shoots, etc. this bad experience i had in portland was the only negative one i've had here and i started modeling in this town over 8 years ago (although is spent most of that time traveling). smaller markets tend to be kinder, but when you are running in the big leagues like Milan, LA, NYC, Paris, London, Miami.....things tend to get uglier.

BTW congrats on having a hot wife! :-D

Airing my dirty laundry at: Peacocks on Leashes

Humor Blog<br />
Top Sites

ModelMom – September 28, 2007 – 8:38am

i've also always looked younger

ModelMom's picture

than my age which is what allowed me to model on an international level even though i started late. at 27 i was still getting work for teen magazines and junior clothing lines. older models who look like grown women i'm sure get treated with more respect. i cant tell you how many times i had to bite my tongue when being talked down to as if i were a child.

but then again i dont want to just focus on the negative. i really have had the most wonderful experiences in my life while modeling. ultimately, it is what you make it. the industry has its standards and if you deviate from them prepare to get slammed. intricate girl described it best with her linebacker analogy. while there are things i disagree with, i'd do it all over again if i could. (i only work on a very part time basis now that i am a stay at home mom!) no more traveling for me!

Airing my dirty laundry at: Peacocks on Leashes

Humor Blog<br />
Top Sites

ModelMom – September 28, 2007 – 8:46am

I can't imagine getting sent home...

That must have been crushing. Good for you, ModelMom, for hanging in there so that you could experience the good as well as the bad!

read me!

Brenna
Blog at Writing UP!
Brenna Fender's Blog

Brenna Fender – October 2, 2007 – 9:05am

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.