America's Next Top Model Goes Beyond Trainwreckage
Oh man, where do I start on this one.....
Well, ashamed as I should be to admit it, I do take in all of the reality (reality my ass) shows that have to do with the modeling world. Perhaps I'm attracted to this offal because I've been a part of the Industry for over 8 years now and I'm apparently also a glutton for punishment. So it is what it is, and I shouldn't complain about how AWFUL ANTM is, but I am gonna rant about it because why the heck not?!
As a quick side note I want to say that "The Agency" on VH1 and Petra Nemcova's "A Model Life" on TLC were really good modeling based reality shows that were pretty damned realistic and the models in it were actually capable of making very good careers for themselves. They were young, tall, thin and beautiful (some conventional, some exotic, some quirky). Perfect fodder for fashion. ANTM on
the other hand has never really quite been great at picking "true" models. They have had very attractive girls on the show, but "attractive"and "modelesque" are two very different things.
In fashion modeling, beauty is all about proportion or all about shock factor. But even the quirkiest girls are fascinating to look at in their androgeny. The girls Tyra picks (with the exception of a few that really could model and subsequently get booted off the show....WTF?) could be perfect news anchors, men's mag girls, or pageant queens....but top fashion models...I beg to differ. This season in particular is hard for me to watch. These are the best girls you could find in the ENTIRE United States? Have mercy.
Only Lisa has any undeniable model potential. Heather is hailed as the quirky beauty and indeed she has a very high fashion look but her personality suffers due to the fact that she has Asperger's Syndrome (and God bless her for going out there and attacking this competition with all her might) but in reality the modeling industry would eat her alive. It is a sink or swim industry without exception. She could win the competition but would she be able to handle it thereafter?
Victoria, the Yale girl, is adorable, also has a great fashion face but her body is not modelesque. Mila, who got kicked off tonight, also had a very oddly pear shaped body which in the real world would be viewed as completely healthy and normal, but for high fashion (okay...I know I am gonna get crucified here) she is (aaaaaaah, am I really gonna say this? ) fat. Big legs, hips and thighs.....not good for modeling especially since they weren't pointing her out as the plus sized girl. They actually never mentioned her weight on the show, perhaps because now it is taboo? Oh, and by fat, I mean "fat for modeling". Sorry, but that is what it is too. I've lived and breathed this industry and been called everything from ethereal to fat assed all in the same day. Seriously.
I in no way am a proponent of models looking like heroin junkies, but high fashion has always used very thin girls as models because the models are in essence just hangers for the couture. Having a J. Lo booty is just not gonna get you a booking with Versace. Believe me. I got sent home from Tokyo for having a big ass.....my hips measured 34.5. The general public may want modeling to be all about looking like a real woman, but that really isn't what the industry is about. Fashion, especially high fashion, is about selling a fantasy. Rail thin, pre pubescent girls without stretchmarks, cellulite or acne (and mainly from Brazil and Eastern Europe....I guess the gene pools there are quite incredible) are a fantasy....so that is why they become top models. Tyra's show is something of a circus side show. I'm not really sure what she is doing....but nothing about the show....and I mean NOTHING is reality based when it comes to modeling.
I just had to put my 2 cents in on this one. Just watched the 2nd episode....and have been rolling my eyes about it so I thought I'd sit and spit out some words then go read a book and re-smart myself. Ha!
Speaking of smart.....VH1 is gonna be airing "America's Most Smartest Model" soon. Also a reality competition....and yes I will be watching it so that I can sit perplexed and pissed at the awful name the competitors will be giving the rest of American models. Thanks guys. Thanks a freakin lot.







Recent comments
9 hours 9 min ago
9 hours 56 min ago
14 hours 29 min ago
22 hours 10 min ago
22 hours 13 min ago
22 hours 28 min ago
23 hours 13 min ago
23 hours 14 min ago
1 day 2 hours ago
1 day 3 hours ago